EU Finance Ministers discussed a possible update of the budgetary rules, in particular those of the Stability and Growth Pact, at the informal meeting in Helsinki on Saturday 14 September, but it is unlikely that a substantial revision of these rules will be on the agenda in the coming months.
“Many colleagues have said that our current fiscal rules are actually working reasonably well, but not perfectly”, said Valdis Dombrovskis, Commissioner for the Euro and Social Dialogue, at the press conference following this informal meeting.
This sentence sums up quite well the feeling that prevailed at the end of the discussion. The latter was based on the report of the European Fiscal Board, published a few days earlier (see EUROPE 12325/17), which gave a mixed overview of the legal framework surrounding budgetary policies.
“The report from the European Fiscal Board provides a good start for the discussions”, said Finnish Finance Minister Mika Lintilä.
Almost all national delegations took the floor to express their views on a possible revision of the rules, taking rather traditional and, therefore, not surprising positions. For example, several southern European Member States have argued the need to take investment into account when assessing compliance with the rules, while Germany has taken a position for less flexibility in their application.
In any case, few ministers seem to be quick to embark on a formal procedure to review these budgetary rules, which would take several years. “I am very cautious about revising the rules”, said Bruno Le Maire, the French Finance Minister, the day before, referring to a “difficult, long and uncertain debate”, if such an option were considered.
It emerged from the discussion that the rules have broadly speaking worked in recent years. “The results are there. The excessive deficit procedure has been brought down, for the first time since the crisis”, Mr Dombrovskis welcomed, referring to Spain's exit from the corrective arm of the Pact in June, the last country in the euro area to be in this situation (see EUROPE 12275/5).
Nevertheless, a reflection on how to improve the existing framework is still possible. Thus, an option presented by the European Fiscal Board, consisting in relying only on public debt and expenditure criteria in assessing compliance with budgetary rules, could be an avenue to explore. It remains to be seen whether or not some changes in the assessment criteria would involve a formal change in the rules.
The Commission must review these budgetary rules before the end of the year, which could serve as a basis for the work of the major European finance ministers in the new institutional cycle. (Original version in French by Lucas Tripoteau)