login
login
Image header Agence Europe
Europe Daily Bulletin No. 12379
Contents Publication in full By article 13 / 35
ECONOMY - FINANCE - BUSINESS / Taxation

Adoption in Competitiveness Council of proposal on country-by-country reporting blocked by 12 Member States

In the end, there was no vote during the Competitiveness Council on Thursday, 28 November, on the proposal on country-by-country reporting (CBCR), which would require companies to publicly disclose certain accounting data such as their turnover.

In fact, 12 Member States have publicly declared their opposition to the text. Therefore, the required qualified majority could not be achieved to the nearest Member State.

Nevertheless, for the Finnish Presidency of the Council of the EU, this is not a failure. When questioned by EUROPE, Finnish Minister of Employment Timo Harakka stated that his country had at least succeeded in reviving the subject at the ministerial level. “We knew the majority would be slim”, he admitted.

The promise of transparency has also been half kept. While the debate was public, there was a one-hour break, leaving room for last-minute negotiations behind closed doors.

The Finnish Presidency and the European Commission began by reiterating that the proposal was not a tax text and did not affect the tax sovereignty of Member States in any way.

“Colleagues, this deadlock has to end. I believe we should really ask ourselves: do we want to provide consumers and other stakeholders with more relevant companies information? Do we want to foster openness? I believe we all do and we all agree with this aim”, declared Timo Harakka, encouraging Member States to support the compromise proposal on the table.

But Luxembourg, Latvia, Slovenia, Ireland, Estonia, Austria, Sweden, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Croatia, Cyprus, and Malta decided otherwise. In a joint declaration signed by these countries with the exception of Croatia and Austria, they invoke the question of legal basis.

They “completely agree with the analysis of the EU Council’s Legal Service” from November 2016, which states that the proposal must be unanimously negotiated as a tax text and on simple consultation of the European Parliament (see EUROPE 11758/9). As a result, they are requesting that the text be referred back to the Economic and Financial Affairs (Ecofin) Council.

“It feels a little bit awkward to me to be speaking here on a directive which I have personally negotiated and voted for 3 years ago. Because this directive was negotiated in the Ecofin and on that occasion I can assure you that the fact of publicizing or not the taxes of companies was discussed and the decision was not to do it”, stated Luxembourg’s Minister of Finance Pierre Gramegna.

The Latvian and Maltese ministers even went so far as to say that opening the way for a qualified-majority decision on this issue could set a “dangerous precedent”.

As expected, Germany announced that it would abstain in the event of a vote, explaining that its position had not yet been determined (see EUROPE 12374/22). The United Kingdom had already announced its intention to delegate its vote to the Finnish Presidency.

However, Spain, Denmark, Italy, the Netherlands, Romania, Belgium, Portugal, Slovakia, Lithuania, Greece, France, Poland, and Bulgaria have declared their support for the compromise text on the table.

To counter the arguments of the other Member States, these countries suggested that greater emphasis be placed on the freedom of establishment and the objective of transparency so that the legal basis chosen in the text could not be called into question.

A letdown

For the stakeholders who were expecting a lot from this meeting, it was a letdown. Civil society organisations—such as Transparency International, Eurodad, Oxfam, and ActionAid, which have been very active on the matter (see EUROPE 12378/28)—have expressed their disappointment at the persistent deadlock in the [Competitiveness] Council.

The European Parliament, which had also continually put pressure on the [Competitiveness] Council (see EUROPE 12356/10), reacted quickly. “The failure of today’s negotiations is an outrage that shows the influence still possessed by those who put opacity and the interests of companies before those of citizens”, declared Marie Toussaint (Greens/EFA, France) in a statement.

“It is simply unacceptable that some member states hide behind legalistic aspects to prevent progress on tax transparency, which citizens and parliamentarians have been demanding for years”, stated Evelyn Regner of Austria and Ibán García del Blanco of Spain on behalf of the S&D group.

Before the press, Commissioner for Growth Jyrki Katainen also lamented the failure of the discussions and hoped that the proposal would one day succeed.

What are the next steps?

The future of the legislative proposal remains very uncertain. At the end of the meeting, Finland committed to continue working on the text until the end of its presidency.

According to Timo Harakka, since “the legal basis is taking the discussion hostage”, it is thus necessary to try to find a legal basis that is able to satisfy the legal services of the Commission, the EU Council, and the European Parliament.

It should be noted that Croatia, which will take over the Presidency of the Council of the EU in January, came down against the proposal. Nevertheless, the country promised to continue to think about how to come to a solution that will provide “the necessary legal certainty and sustainability”.

In Mr Gramegna’s opinion, referring the text back to the Member State permanent representative (Coreper) level would quite simply be pointless. The Luxembourg minister asked that the text be formally discussed during the Ecofin Council next week. At present, only one information point on this subject is reportedly on the European finance ministers’ agenda. (Original version in French by Marion Fontana with Pascal Hansens)

Contents

SECTORAL POLICIES
ECONOMY - FINANCE - BUSINESS
EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT PLENARY
COURT OF JUSTICE OF THE EU
COUNCIL OF EUROPE
NEWS BRIEFS