login
login
Image header Agence Europe
Europe Daily Bulletin No. 13971
SECTORAL POLICIES / Energy

At ‘Energy’ Council, first political discussions on network charges turn into legal tangle

The energy ministers from European Union Member States held their first formal political discussion on the European Commission’s proposal regarding network charges at the ‘Energy’ Council in Luxembourg on Thursday 29 October.

The proposal, presented on 17 July, aims to lower prices and encourage users to switch from gas to electricity by ensuring that taxes on electricity are no higher than those on gas (see EUROPE 13912/7).

A legal issue. The ministers’ speeches focused almost unanimously on the proposal’s legal basis and the conflict of competences over taxation, a point that had already been raised during technical-level discussions (see EUROPE 13968/7).

In particular, the ministers pointed to an opinion from the EU Council’s Legal Service concerning certain provisions, among them Article 18c, which relates to the taxation of electricity and promoting a lower rate for electricity than for gas. This provision, argued a majority of Member States, should be removed. The legal opinion, which is not publicly available, was reportedly delivered orally at a meeting of the EU Council’s Working Party on Energy.

According to the ministers, any decision on taxation should be left to the revision of the Energy Taxation Directive, otherwise there would be a risk of “creating a precedent”, said Austrian Deputy Permanent Representative Franz Wirtenberger. However, after four years of discussions, economy and finance ministers had still not reached a compromise on energy taxation by November 2025, prompting the then Danish Presidency of the EU Council to abandon the effort (see EUROPE 13751/14).

Many EU energy ministers are calling for Article 113 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) to serve as the legal basis for this taxation issue, rather than Article 194(2) TFEU, which the Commission chose as the legal basis.

The Commission maintains that the proposal it has put forward is workable and complies with EU law. The initial proposal of 17 July states that “the targeted fiscal measures are purely ancillary to the primary objective of the energy system – ensuring the functioning of the energy market” and that “these measures consist of general principles and clarifications and complement the existing harmonised EU framework”.

Nevertheless, on Thursday 29 October, European Commissioner for Energy Dan Jørgensen assured Member States that he had taken careful note of their concerns about the proposal’s taxation provisions. Irish Energy Minister Darragh O’Brien did the same.

Compromise proposals. Greek Energy Minister Stavros Papastavrou proposed a joint meeting with the finance ministers to discuss the issue. His proposal was supported by the Bulgarian, Slovak and Romanian energy ministers.

In a spirit of compromise, Luxembourg suggested replacing the much-criticised taxation provisions with a general obligation for Member States to promote electrification and improve the ratio between gas and electricity prices. (Original version in French by Nadège Delépine)

Contents

ECONOMY - FINANCE - BUSINESS
SECTORAL POLICIES
EXTERNAL ACTION
INSTITUTIONAL
SECURITY - DEFENCE - SPACE
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS - SOCIETAL ISSUES
COUNCIL OF EUROPE
NEWS BRIEFS